LAUSANNE. Init7 has asked the Federal Court to put back a competition fine against Swisscom that a lower court cancelled in October. The Winterthur internet provider filed the appeal on 11 November. The fine was CHF 18.4 million. The Federal Administrative Court set it aside on 13 October. The federal department that oversees the Competition Commission has decided not to appeal. Init7 has, and it has called that official refusal a political choice.

The dispute is about how fibre is built. From 2020 Swisscom used a point-to-multipoint layout: one line to a street shaft, then a split out to the buildings. Rivals say that design stops them renting a continuous fibre of their own, which is the point-to-point layout they argue the market needs. The Competition Commission treated the build as an abuse, froze it with interim measures, and in December 2023 imposed the sanction. The administrative court decided the commission had been wrong to find a breach of cartel law, because Swisscom did not hold a dominant position on the market the case was really about.

The reasoning Init7 says is circular

The fine is lifted. The competitor, not the competition authority, is the one still in court.

Init7’s lawyers attack that step as a loop. The court, they argue, found that Swisscom is not on the point-to-point market because Swisscom refuses to build point-to-point, and then found that a firm which is not on that market cannot dominate it. A competitor that sells connections at 25 gigabits a second says the court skipped both the technical record and the way cartel law usually treats a network owner. The company wants the Federal Court to admit the appeal, correct the reading, and restore the interim measures the Federal Court itself upheld in 2022, so that a point-to-multipoint network cannot be finished while the case is still about whether that network is lawful.

None of those wishes is a judgment. The Federal Court has not said it will hear the case in full, and it has not said the fine returns. A competitor’s appeal is a narrower instrument than an appeal by the authority. Init7 can press its own legal interest. It cannot rewind the department’s decision to stop. Readers should keep those two facts apart: the state has stepped back, and a private firm has stepped in.

What does not change in your street this week

An open cabinet on a pavement is not a ruling. If Swisscom, or a local utility building with it, is already splicing in your commune, Monday’s news does not order them to pull the cable out. The interim measures Init7 wants restored are a request, not a fresh order. Households choosing a provider should compare the product they can actually buy: speed, price, and whether a second operator can light a line into the building. The court file is about whether that second line was unlawfully designed out. It is not a discount code.

The political charge is Init7’s, and it should be labelled as theirs. The company says the Federal Council, by letting the department drop the appeal, is clearing competition out of the telecoms market and damaging cartel law. Swisscom’s position, upheld for now by the administrative court, is that the legal test for dominance was not met. Between those two sentences sits a court that has not yet spoken. Swisscom is already due to take on a different public job, processing e-voting data from 2028, which is a separate contract and a separate argument. Mixing the fibre case with the ballot box does not make either of them clearer.

The only timetable that exists

Mark 11 November as the day the appeal went in, 13 October as the day the fine was lifted, and 2022 as the year the interim measures were last confirmed higher up. There is no hearing date to put in a diary. Until the Federal Court says whether it will enter the case, the law in force is the administrative court’s: the CHF 18.4 million does not stand, and the build method that produced it has not been banned again. Anyone signing a multi-year fibre contract this month should read the service, not the lawsuit.