LAUSANNE. Yves Donzallaz has withdrawn his candidacy for re-election to the Federal Supreme Court. The judicial commission has recommended that Beatrice van de Graaf, the other judge in the relationship that triggered the affair, be re-elected. The two outcomes, reported on Thursday, lower the temperature of a vote parliament must still hold, and they do it by removing one of the two people the vote was going to be about.
Donzallaz sits without a party. Van de Graaf is a judge of the Swiss People’s Party. They have said the relationship lasted about eleven months and ended at Easter this year. The court has since held that a relationship of that kind breached the rule against a lasting cohabitation between federal judges, because two judges who share a life cannot be counted as two independent votes. The court held a public hearing on whether rulings they touched must be reopened. Thursday’s news is about their jobs, not about those rulings.
Why one leaves and one stays
After the legal finding, both careers looked exposed. The commission was not expected to put either name forward with any comfort. Donzallaz then took himself off the list. Van de Graaf stayed on it, and the commission chose to recommend her. That is an institutional decision, not a finding that one half of a relationship is innocent. It is a finding that parliament can be asked to keep one judge and will not be asked to keep the other. The reasons he withdrew are his. The reason she can be voted on is that the commission said yes.
The affair became public at the end of April, after a report in Weltwoche. Soon afterwards Donzallaz found a hidden camera in the hedge at his home. The Valais prosecutor is investigating that intrusion. It is a separate case from the re-election, and it is not a reason to treat the judge as a suspect in his own private life. It is a reminder that the story stopped being only about a rule in the Judges’ Act the moment someone pointed a camera at a house.
What parliament still has to do
Federal judges are elected by parliament, not by the court. A recommendation from the judicial commission usually holds. It does not have to. Members who wanted a debate about both judges will now have to decide whether a debate about one judge, and about the rule she was found to have broken, is still the debate they wanted. Members who wanted the affair to end before the election have been given most of what they asked for. One name is gone.
The revision requests against judgments do not disappear because a candidacy did. A litigant who has asked for a case to be reopened is waiting on the court’s test, not on the commission’s ballot. The public, meanwhile, has a clearer picture than it had a week ago. Donzallaz will not stand again. Van de Graaf will, with the commission’s recommendation. The relationship that caused both facts has already ended. The cases it touched have not.