ZURICH. The Federal Council is right about the paperwork. A single digital way to leave a health insurer would be a better system than fifty company habits and a registered letter. It would also arrive too late for anyone who wants a different premium on 1 January. The motion is a recommendation to parliament. The deadline is a date. The date is 30 November.

A little more than 8 per cent of people switch in a year. That is not evidence of a market working. It is evidence of a market people cannot be bothered to exit, which is a different economic fact. Basic insurance must take you. The benefits are set in federal law. The fear of being refused, or of a gap in cover, is the wrong fear. The right fear is a letter that arrives on 1 December and does nothing.

Write first, then enjoy the debate

A button in a future law does not post a letter in November.

Compare the basic premium for your age, your canton and your deductible. Check accident cover if your employer does not already provide it. Write to the insurer you are leaving so the notice is in their hands by 30 November, and use registered post if you are inside the last few days. Keep the receipt. Join the new insurer for 1 January. Then, if you like, follow the argument in Bern about a button.

Léonore Porchet is also right to doubt that competition, on its own, tames the premium. The average is already up 4.9 per cent, the fifth rise in a row. Easier switching will not repeal the cost of care. It will let a household stop paying the lazy price, which is the price of staying because the form was annoying. Those are different public goods. Parliament can pursue the first. You can do the second this week.

The insurer is a judgment, not only a bill

There is a second reason not to treat this as a pure price errand. When a drug is not on the Specialities List, the insurer decides whether to pay. Those decisions already diverge, from a near-automatic yes at some companies to a refusal more than half the time at others. A cheaper premium at a company that says no to the awkward case is not a saving if you are the awkward case. Read the premium. Remember the exception. Do not confuse either of them with a motion that has not been voted.

The click will be worth having when it exists. It does not exist today. The post does. Use it before the 30th, or accept the policy you already have and stop pretending a debate in the Federal Palace has cancelled it for you.